MechMate CNC Router Forum

Go Back   MechMate CNC Router Forum > Common Assemblies & Parts > Motors & their mountings
Register Options Profile Last 1 | 3 | 7 Days Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read

Reply
 
Thread Tools
  #1  
Old Tue 31 May 2016, 08:52
tcheney2000
Just call me: Terry
 
Victoria, Texas
United States of America
Teknic Motor Question

I ran across this awhile back. Anyone have any input?
https://www.teknic.com/products/clea...-servo-motors/
I am finally getting serious about building a custom machine. This showed up in my inbox last year. It's supposed to be a small servo motor but take the input from a stepper driver. Just curious...
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old Tue 31 May 2016, 14:05
islaww
Just call me: Gary C
 
UP of Michigan
United States of America
Terry...
I have used a couple dozen of them on various projects. They are a brushless DC servo, with an integrated drive, so they do no require one. Step and direction signals can come straight from the pin or I/O board. Make sure you do your torque, reduction and rpm calcs well as they have a number of products with a finite power and rpm range.
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old Tue 31 May 2016, 14:27
tcheney2000
Just call me: Terry
 
Victoria, Texas
United States of America
I have a client that has a ShopBot and wants to speed up the jog speed. Will these work with the ShopBot control?
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old Tue 31 May 2016, 14:32
tcheney2000
Just call me: Terry
 
Victoria, Texas
United States of America
Also on my project I want to make a rather large cnc turning center for turning long posts. Are these strong enough to turn and hold the post while the spindle is cutting a pattern ( like on an a 8" square post?)
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old Tue 31 May 2016, 18:19
islaww
Just call me: Gary C
 
UP of Michigan
United States of America
Terry...
Give me a call at (906) 273-1455. I've done a good number of systems for old ShopBots
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old Thu 08 February 2018, 06:33
WilliamT
Just call me: BillT #111
 
Georgetown, TX
United States of America
I use these servos and I like um...

Just noticed this thread. Sorry for the late reply.

I have these servos mounted to a MechMate and a Bridgeport in Austin. Send a pm if you are interested to see them run.
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old Thu 12 July 2018, 09:26
ayetti
Just call me: Alex
 
SLO california
United States of America
Quote:
Originally Posted by WilliamT View Post
Just noticed this thread. Sorry for the late reply.

I have these servos mounted to a MechMate .
Which motors did you use for the mechmate Bill? Iíve been looking over there motors and wasnít quite sure. I think itís a pretty clear upgrade for me to make though, just ironing out the details. I intend to use a centroid acorn controller.
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old Thu 12 July 2018, 14:16
WilliamT
Just call me: BillT #111
 
Georgetown, TX
United States of America
Alex - Thanks for the note.

I'm using CPM-SDSK-2310S-RLN. They are little NEMA23's and were the least expensive when purchased a few years ago.

After fighting control problems for more than two years, I dumped the steppers, I drank the Teknic Kool Aid and bought four of these little guys for the MM. A more professional Hicon controller was added. What a difference!!

The 2310S-RLN incorporate a lower resolution controller. I have no way to measure whether the higher resolution servos run smoother. But for my machine and my applications, they are quite accurate and suite my needs well.

My MM is a larger version, with a 6' x 12' operating envelope with a 10"z. The gantry is heavy. The little 23's drive a reduction boxes, 4.5:1, 16 tooth x 72 tooth. During performance testing the servos drove the table exceeding 400-IPM, and there was more to go. But I'm sure they can easily drive this large gantry with 3:1 boxes.

I too have a Centroid Controller on the shelf waiting for time to upgrade. It will be interesting to see how well it performs on the MechMate..

Last edited by WilliamT; Thu 12 July 2018 at 14:32.. Reason: typo
Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old Thu 12 July 2018, 18:20
Allegheny
Just call me: Brian
 
Massachusetts
United States of America
Quote:
Originally Posted by WilliamT View Post
Just noticed this thread. Sorry for the late reply.

I have these servos mounted to a MechMate and a Bridgeport in Austin. Send a pm if you are interested to see them run.
Hi BillT,

What motors did you use for the Bridgeport? I'm planning to convert an Induma 1s this fall/winter (an Italian vertical turret mill like a BP on steroids - weighs 3,300#) and have been looking at the ClearPath/Acorn option. I'd also be interested in looking at Tecknics.

Thanx,
Brian in Taxachusetts
Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old Fri 13 July 2018, 12:48
WilliamT
Just call me: BillT #111
 
Georgetown, TX
United States of America
Brian,

I used the same servo on all three axis, a Clearpath CPM-SDHP-3441D-ELN. You can find them here:
https://www.teknic.com/model-info/CP..._voltage=75VDC

It is very important to know the performance of these servos can only be achieved by driving them with a proper power supply at the rated voltage of 75VDC. I chose the Teknic power supply STS-EMF75, now a legacy of theirs, but perhaps still available. It is listed at the bottom of this page. https://www.teknic.com/products/lega...gacy-products/

Two points quickly..

1) I'm using the same servo to drive the Z axis, as I bought the ClearPath stuff before rebuilding the machine. When I rebuilt the head, I weighed the quill and found its weight to be 20lbs. After I installed the ball screw setup to drive the quill I found that I could easily turn the screw by hand with little force to move the quill up and down. The large servo I have on the Z axis is totally inefficient and I can easily use a smaller one.

2)Over the years, the price of servo motors and controllers have come down. Manufactures are trying to capture more of the hobby market. We've seen this with Centroid whereby, they introduced the ACORN controller. Hicon now offers a less expensive professional controller. And DMM, Dynamic Motor Motion has introduced a complete servo package for machines like the Bridgeport. Find it here: http://www.dmm-tech.com/multiaxissolutions2.html

Let's consider the cost of my ClearPath stuff. Three servos, a power supply, and a Hicon controller cost me approx, $3,200 plus cabling and the labor to build the cables. Today, I can purchase a complete DMM system for the Bridgeport for a little over $1,500; a complete 'Turn Key' system. That's a savings of $1,700 bucks.

I really like the ClearPath stuff. It is cool, easy to setup and for me, trouble free. But to have $1,700 more dollars to spend on the machine elsewhere. You can easily apply that money to a set of digital scales.

There are many more options available today than were available four years ago when I purchased my equipment. Today, I would give the DMM serious consideration.

BillT
Reply With Quote
  #11  
Old Wed 18 July 2018, 05:57
MetalHead
Just call me: Mike
 
Columbiana AL
United States of America
I am glad to hear we have a MechMate running the Teknic motors. I would love to see some pictures of your setup. Particulalry how the 23 series gear reduction is setup. I also want to see an Acorn controller in action on a MechMate. I think this combination in the next step in the electronics for the MechMate.
Reply With Quote
  #12  
Old Wed 18 July 2018, 10:50
WilliamT
Just call me: BillT #111
 
Georgetown, TX
United States of America
Sure, I'll begin to put the information together. Perhaps it is best to start a fresh thread on the ClearPath servos with the Acorn controller. There we can discuss my setup, the good, the bad, and future improvements where needed. This could be a very informative thread and a lot of fun.
Reply With Quote
  #13  
Old Thu 19 July 2018, 06:46
jhiggins7
Just call me: John #26
 
Hebron, Ohio
United States of America
Hey Bill,

I look forward to your new thread regarding Clearpath servo's etc. Clearly, you have pioneered a whole new and promising approach to driving the MechMate.
Reply With Quote
  #14  
Old Sun 03 February 2019, 13:11
Panovak
Just call me: Paul
 
St. Paul
United States of America
will the DMM work for the mechmate? you mentioned it for the bridgeport.
Reply With Quote
  #15  
Old Sun 03 February 2019, 13:12
Panovak
Just call me: Paul
 
St. Paul
United States of America
Quote:
Originally Posted by WilliamT View Post
Brian,


Let's consider the cost of my ClearPath stuff. Three servos, a power supply, and a Hicon controller cost me approx, $3,200 plus cabling and the labor to build the cables. Today, I can purchase a complete DMM system for the Bridgeport for a little over $1,500; a complete 'Turn Key' system. That's a savings of $1,700 bucks.



BillT

will the DMM work with the mechmate? Thanks
Reply With Quote
  #16  
Old Mon 04 February 2019, 16:07
WilliamT
Just call me: BillT #111
 
Georgetown, TX
United States of America
Absolutely, this will work with the MechMate. It's a true 5axis professional controller. You won't need Gecko's or SmoothStepper with this stuff.

And if you want to drive the Gantry with two servos, it can easily be done with the DMM.

Full Disclosure! I do not work with, or for DMM. I do not have association with anyone there. I am not paid or compensated by DMM or anyone there. But I have spoken to a couple of people that have switched their control system to DMM. They like it and have no complaints. Great Price Point, great documentation, good recommendations.

As I've said in the past, I've chased a lot of ghosts with the hobby class controllers and equipment. So for me, the DMM equipment have a lot of positives going for it with very few negatives. When I have a chance I will make this conversion on my MM and Bridgeport, I will post here..

You will find the following links helpful.

Product pricing page:
http://www.dmm-tech.com/multiaxissolutions2.html

The Controller BreakOut Board Manual is here. Comes complete with a lot of wiring information and Mach3 setup information as well.
http://www.dmm-tech.com/Files/DMB425...tVer010106.pdf

Mach3 Mill XML file for use with Mach3 is here.
http://www.dmm-tech.com/Files/Mach3Mill_DMB4250-8B.xml
Reply With Quote
  #17  
Old Mon 11 February 2019, 17:56
Panovak
Just call me: Paul
 
St. Paul
United States of America
Thanks for the information. Still doing a lot of research. Right now my plan is for dmm dyn4 with acorn controller. I'm trying to learn about gearing to see what I should be doing. Some have mentioned I could use direct drive with servo but I'm not so sure
Reply With Quote
  #18  
Old Tue 12 February 2019, 09:37
WilliamT
Just call me: BillT #111
 
Georgetown, TX
United States of America
I would like to apologize for an error in my previous post!!

Earlier I said that the DMM Breakout boards is a true 5 axis controller. Sorry for the error earlier. The DMM board is a 4 axis controller, but is has the additional controller for the second Gantry drive, typically used for larger Gantry systems. The Axis porting is, X-axis and a second X'-axis if needed for the Gantry. And then of course Y-axis and Z-axis. And then the 4th port, the A-axis can be used for a rotary setup if desired.

Sure, the DMM servos can be setup as direct drive. Given a speed rating of 3,000 rpm, but can be over driven to 5,000, and a 16 bit encoder with unbelievable positional accuracy, you have the option to install the servo any way you want, 1:1, 2:1, 3:1.... You will have enough power to break any tooling you attach to your router/spindle, and you will have enough power/velocity to launch the gantry right off the end of the table into your neighbors yard, breaking the stops off in the process. Go have some fun
Reply With Quote
  #19  
Old Tue 12 February 2019, 10:36
digit
Just call me: Dominic
 
Quebec
Canada
Which motor would you suggest for 1:1 ratio (kW).

And I am wondering how to auto-tune a gantry with slave motor ?
Reply With Quote
  #20  
Old Thu 28 February 2019, 07:20
WilliamT
Just call me: BillT #111
 
Georgetown, TX
United States of America
Good question regarding ratios. Are we talking here about gearbox ratios, or the overall drive ratio of the axis?

My MM is configured with DP5 rack, as most guys have done with their MM's and I am using a 20 tooth pinion. And between the pinion gear and the servo is a simple 4.5:1 timing belt gearbox assembly.

To determine the overall drive ratio I used the following data gathered for my MechMate and then measured the result for accuracy. A static measurement confirmed the simple formula correct. The result indicate my servo drive system with a gearbox ratio of 4.5:1 yields a final Under Driven system, 0.702 : 1.

Let's say, perhaps I exchange my gearbox ratio with a 3:1 instead of the 4.5:1. Then my effective overall final ration would be 1.187:1, slightly Over Driven using the same rack and pinion gear. Of course you could dial in a 1:1 by changing any of the gears/pinion.

Driver Recommendation

I do not have a recommendation for drive motors for a 1:1 system. Simply because there are a lot of variables among builders and builder applications. Perhaps some of my data can provide insight.

As I have said before I am using the least expensive ClearPath Servo, CPM-SDSK-2310S-RLN. I am using two of them to drive the X-Axis; my complete gantry weight exceeds 125lbs. These servos can propel the gantry beyond 600ipm, but I keep the machine set much lower, 100ipm.

The quick specs of the servo: 45oz continuous; 220oz peak, 100watts. So looking at the specs; they really look anemic. (https://www.teknic.com/model-info/CPM-SDSK-2310S-RLN/) But in practice, I have never been disappointed with the speed, accuracy, or the performance of these servos. If you look at DMM, their small servos are 400watt. Clearly the small DMM servos can provide all the power you will ever need on a MM. And even smaller servos form Clearpath, like mine can perform quite well. There are many, many choices out in today's market. But one thing I have found to be true, you cannot compare servo specifications with stepper specifications. My 400oz steppers never, ever performed like these little servos. No matter how you measure them, my steppers were a two year disappointment, nightmare.

Multiple Axis Tuning

The guys at Teknic put together a little PDF discussing multiple axis tuning. Obviously this applies to Clearpath, but the logic behind should apply to other manufactured systems.

https://www.teknic.com/files/downloa...Motor-Axis.pdf


===========================

Examine Rack

Rack System = DP5 (Ratio= 20 : 6.333)
Rack = 6.33 threads per inch
Pinion = 20 threads per revolution

Examine Transmission Box
Gear Box Transmission =XL Profile (Ratio= 16 : 72) 4.5:1
Driver = 16 teeth teeth per revolution
Driven = 72 teeth teeth per revolution

Examine Effective Gearbox / Rack & Pinion Ratio Per Revolution
using a simple compound gear ratio method found here, https://woodgears.ca/gear/ratio.html, apply using my gear train data
Ratio = (16 x 20) / (72 x 6.33)
= 320 / 455.76
= 0.7021 Inch Per Revolution of servo
Reply With Quote
  #21  
Old Thu 28 February 2019, 21:46
WilliamT
Just call me: BillT #111
 
Georgetown, TX
United States of America
Correction Previous Post

Earlier I labeled my pinion as DP5. The pinion is DP20. Sorry for the confusion
Reply With Quote
  #22  
Old Mon 13 May 2019, 03:35
supremacy
Just call me: supremacy
 
gaj
Poland
witam
Reply With Quote
  #23  
Old Wed 11 September 2019, 05:37
Ronwalk
Just call me: Ron
 
Springfield, MO
United States of America
Clearpath Motors

So, I am looking at buying these Clearpath motors. There are so many options. I am no engineer and I don't know all these formulas to calculate what I need. I see thread about the smaller motors, but after going through all this process and work, I don't want to cut the costs down with picking cheaper motors. So, the question, to those you actually know, is which motor would you pick if the price was not in play? I like the Acorn bob, but it seems to only be a 12V setup, so I am not sure about the 75V setup. Any input would be helpful
Reply With Quote
  #24  
Old Fri 13 September 2019, 04:13
Tom Ayres
Just call me: Tom #117
 
Bassett (VA)
United States of America
Ron, personally I would do the NEMA 34 sized guys , it stays inline with current setup without mods (and goes good with my setup). The flip side of that is "do you need that much power"? If your set up is with a screw drive then stick to the smaller 23's because the torque and speed of these are great. I can't say much about the voltage setup, its been so long since I've looked at the Acorn to even know what it requires to operate. I do know this, they are both separate, the bob at one voltage the motors at another, and both of those sound correct. Just do your due diligence and you'll be fine. Good luck.
Reply With Quote
  #25  
Old Fri 13 September 2019, 07:52
racedirector
Just call me: Bruce #122
 
New South Wales
Australia
Hi Ron, I echo Toms statement, I would go NEMA 34's too. BTW, Centroid Acorn is the best thing I ever did for my machine. It is 24V not 12 and works fine with my 80V Leadshine drives. Totally different power supplies for both.
Reply With Quote
Reply

Register Options Profile Last 1 | 3 | 7 Days Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read

Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
stepper motor question??? tldj55 General - MM Build 11 Wed 10 August 2011 06:24
Question about stepper drives and motor direction DTGuitars 701. Motor Drives 13 Mon 18 October 2010 10:38
Nema 42 Motor Size Question 15mgtar Driving Mechanisms: Rack/pinion, gears, screws, belts & chains 10 Fri 09 April 2010 03:39
True Torque of a Servo motor for comparison to a Stepper motor, when used in a router Mcyoda Motors & their mountings 3 Tue 19 August 2008 01:50
What does a stepper motor look like inside? (geared Oriental Motor) Gerald D Motors & their mountings 0 Sat 16 August 2008 09:29


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 22:11.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.3
Copyright ©2000 - 2019, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.